Part A:
First off I have to start by saying, I think out of all the
assignments we have written, researched and taken part in, this one was by far
the most challenging! I’ve heard silly jokes that women can’t go 5 minutes, let
alone 15 minutes without interrupting a conversation; with that being said, I’m
interested in how this worked out for the males in this class to see if they
find it as “challenging” as women supposedly do.
I wanted this assignment to really test me. So instead of
sitting within a group of friends and listening, which I find easier to do, I
sat and listened to my boyfriend… for 15 minutes straight. Not a word escaped
my mouth, but OMG was there ever a few I wanted to say after! It was extremely
challenging just listening and not being able speak. Also, after realizing how much I rolled my
eyes, I knew I had to find new ways through body language to actually try to
communicate with him. This also posed a huge challenge, my actions were
interrupted in different ways then they were meant, which was so FRUSTRATING. So
instead of agreeing with him and encouraging the ideas he was talking about, my
crazy hand gestures, followed with extreme spasmodic head nods, discouraged him
to continue talking about one topic and moved to another, which I didn’t want. Also, these actions may have scared him into thinking I was going into a seizure.
After this assignment was finished, I wanted to see if maybe he was just challenging me, to see if I wouldn't say anything to the somewhat outrageous comments and sports commentaries given. So throughout the weekend I tried to listen more, without saying anything. It was crazy how much more he opened up with the time I didn't interrupt him.
Chase (my boyfriend) is an amazingly patient person who always just wants to help. By doing this assignment I realized that a lot more can come out of just listening to a person then continuously interrupting someone. Although, I still stand by what I said previously about it being rather frustrating not being able to "properly" communicate with words. I am lucky I had Chase to work with on this assignment, we both challenge each other and push each other, and this made for an eye opening experience, in more ways then one. First, like mentioned earlier, actually listening and learning from him and secondly, to think about how communication through voice is crucial. Those who cannot speak are at a disadvantageous to actually being heard, not in a "vocal cord" sense, but by being misunderstood, miscommunicated with and ultimately blocked by a "talking barrier". Those who know sign language can communicate, but based off this assignment if they didn't know it, it would be so incredibly hard.
Part B:
This part really ticked me off. It was bad enough having to
sit and listen the day before and try to communicate through gestures, but now
I have to be monotone… which as lame as this sounds, I needed to practice the
night before at. HOW INCREDIBLY HARD not allowing any expression in your voice.
I once had a professor in a class of 250 students that was monotone, and it was
the most challenging class. It was hard to “get into” the lectures given, and
it was hard to be interested in the topics discussed… and la de da same thing
happened to me when I had no expression in my voice. Pretty sure everyone lost
interested, and the first thing said after I made a comment was, “Why are you
talking so weird?” I explained to the group of people what I was doing, and of
course it became a game of “lets get her to talk the most.” The other part that
I could BARELY grasp was not using hand gestures or body language! OMG I talk
with my hands so much, it’s like I’m trying to land a plane. So, besides not
allowing any altering in my tones, I wasn’t allowed to express myself through
body movement, which was so hard. I realized the same thing occurred as what
happened in Part A; I was misunderstood on EVERYTHING I was saying. If I meant
one thing, to them it meant another. If I was excited about another, it seemed
as though I disliked it. If I truly despised something, it was as though I was
neutral on the idea.
Body language is also crucial for communication, which makes me think about those who cannot read body language. Wether visually impaired or just cannot differentiate from one body language sign to the next. This will create miscommunication between parties, which is unfortunate. The people I worked with for this assignment instantly knew something was different about the way I was talking and acting...but what if they didn't know it was an assignment and it was the first time we were meeting?
Both scenarios of just listening and creating body language (not using sign language) and not allowed to use body language only mono-toned speech opened my eyes to the problems of communication. For those that can't physically participate in it, and to those that can but are misunderstood, communication is a huge part in todays world and society. This assignment was challenging, eye-opening and perplexing.
Your insight into Part A of the advantages of not speaking (namely listening), was interesting but I was relieved to see that you also recognized the limitations, namely being able to communicate easily, which was the key here!
ReplyDeleteI do really like your question regarding the differences in male and female experiences. I'm sure there is a difference and that would be a fascinating experiment and I suspect there would indeed be difference. Who do you think talks more with their hands, men or women?
Loved your experience in Part B. If you express yourself as enthusiastically with your hands as you do with your writing, I can definitely picture you trying to "land a plane"! I always find it interesting how important body language is to clear communication.
The only thing missing was speculation on any conditions where there might be an advantage to NOT reading body language.
Otherwise, great post.
Hi Carmen,
ReplyDeleteI find your approach with Part A of the assignment to be interesting. I cannot tell you how many times I hear people complain that when they speak others do not know how to listen. I find myself sometimes doing that, not listening that is. I don't do it on purpose, I like talking and I make the mistake of thinking that when people talk to me, I need to respond.
Interesting that your body language during your silence was misinterpreted, but it is good that you recognized that you needed to make a change.
Also, now that I read your post, I too am interested about how the men did with this assignment vs. the women. I have actually been looking to see if any of them have posted so that I can get their insight on it.
I really enjoyed reading your post Carmen.
Thank you,
Marta
I would have to say that women talk more with their hands, only because I feel like we talk a little bit more in general. (lol) I'm basing this off of some of the blogs I read as well. One of the bloggers went as far as to say she "sat on her hands so she wouldn't use them." I felt the same way by placing my hands in my pockets when I was conducting part B. Some females struggle with not placing emotion into their speech, emotion meaning pitch/tone changes, hand gestures and body language.
ReplyDeleteI once read a study that labeled women as emotional beings and men as visual beings. I could see this making sense... women (especially when dishing on the latest gossip from the Bachelorette) have a million different tones to describe each and every scenario, plus the body language to go along. Women use body language in everyday life as well, and with men being visual beings see these signs and approach appropriately. Yes, I use the word "appropriately" because we all know if a girl says "I'm fine" with her eyebrows arched, hand on her hip, and a roll of her eyes, men take those signs into consideration and take caution. :D Us women are complex creatures.
So in answer to who talks more with their hands, women do. All I know is, if I worked at an airport, I could land planes like nobody's business.
LOL! Great reply! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteHaha thats funny. Yeah guys have just as hard time to do this as women. Actually scratch that you guys are worse, but many guys like to talk and hear themselves too. I think you did a good job of answering the questions and put out a good picture of what your experiment was like. Haha i use my hands a lot too! its such a curse, but i think it makes you more interesting to listen too!
ReplyDelete